This list was worked on in conjunction with Jason Bryant at Mat Talk Online over the course of the last year. Anyone referencing this data should credit both Mat Talk Online and New York Wrestling News.
All-Americans were determined by the individuals hometown when listed on their respective college wrestling roster. That is the way the NCAA determines what individuals count toward what states. Unfortunately, this means individuals such as Troy Spratley who are from New York and grew up in New York, are not included in this data.
Currently Joe Solano (1930) and Bob Koster (1957) are the two individuals missing high schools that they attended. Anyone who knows this information, or would like to offer a correction, please provide to nywrestlingnews1@gmail.com.
Since 1929 there have been 198 different individuals from New York that have earned All-American honors. There have been a total of 308 All-American podium finishes.
Most All-Americans by High School
- 15 All-American Finishes by Mepham
- 12 All-American Finishes by Long Beach
- 8 All-American Finishes by Ithaca
- 7 All-American Finishes by Port Jervis, Brentwood, and Chenango Forks
- 6 All-American Finishes by Webster Schroeder, Huntington, Canton, Olean, and Longwood
- 5 All-American Finishes by Hilton
- 4 All-American Finishes by Syosset, Sachem, Wantagh, Shoreham-Wading River, Lansing, Vestal, Niskayuna, Windsor, and Baldwin
4x National Champions
Kyle Dake (Lansing HS, Cornell) – 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013
Yianni Diakomihalis (Hilton HS, Cornell) – 2018, 2019, 2022, 2023
3x National Champions
Ed Banach (Port Jervis HS, Iowa) – 1980, 1981, 1983
2x National Champions
Dave Auble (Ithaca, Cornell) – 1959, 1960
Carl Adams ( Brentwood HS, Iowa State) – 1971, 1972
Lou Banach (Port Jervis HS, Iowa) – 1981, 1983
Jeff Prescott (Olean HS, Penn State) – 1991, 1992
Kerry McCoy (Longwood HS, Penn State) – 1994, 1997
Nick Gwiazdowksi (Duanesburg HS, NC State) – 2014, 2015
Vito Arujau (Syosset HS, Cornell) – 2023, 2024
4x NCAA All-Americans
Ed Banach (Port Jervis HS, Iowa) – 1980 (1st), 1981 (1st), 1982 (2nd), 1983 (1st)
Gregor Gillespie (Webster Schroeder HS, Edinboro) – 2006 (7th), 2007 (1st), 2008 (5th), 2009 (4th)
Troy Nickerson (Chenango Forks HS, Cornell) – 2006 (2nd), 2007 (3rd), 2009 (1st), 2010 (4th)
Kyle Dake (Lansing HS, Cornell) – 2010 (1st), 2011 (1st), 2012 (1st), 2013 (1st)
Nick Gwiadzowski (Duanesburg HS, NC State) – 2012 (8th), 2014 (1st), 2015 (1st), 2016 (2nd)
Yianni Diakomihalis (Hilton HS, Cornell) – 2018 (1st), 2019 (1st), 2022 (1st), 2023 (1st)
Vito Arujau (Syosset HS, Cornell) – 2019 (4th), 2022 (3rd), 2023 (1st), 2024 (1st)
3x NCAA All-Americans
Carl Adams (Brentwood HS, Iowa State) – 1969 (5th), 1971 (1st), 1972 (1st)
Lou Banach (Port Jervis HS, Iowa) – 1981 (1st), 1982 (3rd), 1983 (1st)
Clar Anderson (Olean HS, Auburn) – 1981 (6th), 1983 (1st), 1984 (5th)
Wayne Catan (Bellport HS, Tennessee) – 1983 (7th), 1985 (2nd), 1986 (2nd)
Paul Diekel (Whitehall Central HS, Lehigh) – 1984 (6th), 1985 (3rd), 1986 (5th)
Peter Yozzo (Sayville HS, Lehigh) – 1985 (3rd), 1986 (2nd), 1987 (1st)
Brad Penrith (Windsor HS, Iowa) – 1986 (1st), 1987 (2nd), 1988 (2nd)
Jeff Prescott (Olean HS, Penn State) – 1990 (5th), 1991 (1st), 1992 (1st)
Tom Shifflet (Sweet Home HS, Edinboro) – 1992 (7th), 1993 (6th), 1995 (3rd)
Kerry McCoy (Longwood HS, Penn State) – 1994 (1st), 1995 (3rd), 1997 (1st)
Jesse Jantzen (Shoreham-Wading River HS, Harvard) – 2002 (3rd), 2003 (3rd), 2004 (1st)
Jon Masa (Long Beach HS, Hofstra) – 2003 (7th), 2005 (3rd), 2006 (5th)
Josh Glenn (Johnson City HS, American) – 2006 (4th), 2007 (1st), 2008 (5th)
J.P. O’Connor (Oxford Academy HS, Harvard) – 2007 (5th), 2008 (6th), 2010 (1st)
Brian Realbuto (Somers HS, Cornell) – 2014 (6th), 2015 (2nd), 2017 (5th)
Jacori Teemer (Long Beach HS, Arizona State) – 2021 (4th), 2022 (6th), 2024 (2nd)
NCAA Champions By Year
1929 – Glenn Stafford (Ithaca HS, Cornell) at 175lbs
1940 – Harold Masem (Brooklyn Poly HS, Lehigh) at 145lbs
1952 – Joe Lemyre (Mepham HS, Penn State) at 167lbs
1953 – Frank Bettucci (Ithaca HS, Cornell) at 167lbs
1957 – Joe Gratto (Canton Central HS, Lehigh) at 137lbs
1959 – Dave Auble (Ithaca HS, Cornell) at 123lbs
1960 – Dave Auble (Ithaca HS, Cornell) at 123lbs
1967 – Tom Schlendorf (Calhoun HS, Syracuse) at 191lbs
1968 – Ken Melchior (Lindenhurst HS, Lock Haven) at 115lbs
1971 – Carl Adams (Brentwood HS, Iowa State) at 158lbs
1972 – Carl Adams (Brentwood HS, Iowa State) at 158lbs
1977 – Nick Gallo (Deer Park HS, Hofstra) at 126lbs
1978 – Keith Stearns (Yorkshire Pioneer HS, Oklahoma) at 167lbs
1980 – Ed Banach (Port Jervis HS, Iowa) at 177lbs
1980 – Noel Loban (Copiague HS, Clemson) at 190lbs
1981 – Ed Banach (Port Jervis HS, Iowa) at 177lbs
1981 – Lou Banach (Port Jervis HS, Iowa) at Unlimited
1983 – Clar Anderson (Olean HS, Oklahoma State) at 134lbs
1983 – Ed Banach (Port Jervis HS, Iowa) at 190lbs
1983 – Lou Banach (Port Jervis HS, Iowa) at UNLlbs
1984 – Carl DeStefanis (Locust Valley HS, Penn State) at 118lbs
1985 – Chris Edmond (Freeport HS, Tennessee) at 167lbs
1986 – Brad Penrith (Windsor HS, Iowa) at 126lbs
1987 – Peter Yozzo (Sayville HS, Lehigh) at 142lbs
1991 – Jeff Prescott (Olean HS, Penn State) at 118lbs
1994 – David Hirsch (Clarkstown South HS, Cornell) at 126lbs
1994 – Dean Morrison (Copiague HS, West Virginia) at 177lbs
1994 – Kerry McCoy (Longwood HS, Penn State) at 275lbs
1997 – Kerry McCoy (Longwood HS, Penn State) at 275lbs
1998 – Mitch Clark (Canton HS, Ohio State) at 177lbs
2004 – Jesse Jantzen (Shoreham-Wading River HS, Harvard) at 149lbs
2007 – Gregor Gillespie (Webster Schroeder HS, Edinboro) at 149lbs
2007 – Josh Glenn (Johnson City HS, American) at 197lbs
2009 – Troy Nickerson (Chenango Forks HS, Cornell) at 125lbs
2010 – Kyle Dake (Lansing HS, Cornell) at 141lbs
2010 – J.P. O’Connor (Oxford Academy HS, Harvard) at 157lbs
2011 – Kyle Dake (Lansing HS, Cornell) at 149lbs
2012 – Kyle Dake (Lansing HS, Cornell) at 157lbs
2013 – Kyle Dake (Lansing HS, Cornell) at 165lbs
2014 – Nick Gwiazdowksi (Duanesburg HS, NC State) at 285lbs
2015 – Nick Gwiazdowksi (Duanesburg HS, NC State) at 285lbs
2018 – Yianni Diakomihalis (Hilton HS, Cornell) at 141lbs
2019 – Yianni Diakomihalis (Hilton HS, Cornell) at 141lbs
2022 – Yianni Diakomihalis (Hilton HS, Cornell) at 149lbs
2023 – Vito Arujau (Syosset HS, Cornell) at 133lbs
2023 – Yianni Diakomihalis (Hilton HS, Cornell) at 149lbs
2024 – Vito Arujau (Syosset HS, Cornell) at 133lbs
Every Division I All-American Placement
| Year | Weight | Place | Name | School | Hometown | State | HS |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1929 | 165 | 3 | Robert Warren | Michigan | New York | NY | Brooklyn Poly |
| 1929 | 175 | 1 | Glenn Stafford | Cornell | Ithaca | NY | Ithaca |
| 1929 | 175 | 3 | Leland Heywood | Wisconsin | Stafford | NY | Stafford |
| 1930 | 165 | 3 | Joe Solano | Harvard | Hauppauge | NY | Unknown HS |
| 1931 | 165 | 3 | Bill Shanker | Lehigh | Woodmere | NY | Brooklyn Poly |
| 1938 | 165 | 3 | Henry Wittenberg | CCNY | New York | NY | No HS Experience |
| 1939 | 175 | 2 | Henry Wittenberg | CCNY | New York | NY | No HS Experience |
| 1939 | UNL | 3 | Carmen Falcone | Kent State | Batavia | NY | Batavia |
| 1940 | 145 | 1 | Harold Masem | Lehigh | Brooklyn | NY | Brooklyn Poly |
| 1941 | 136 | 4 | John Castles | Yale | New York | NY | Andover |
| 1949 | 155 | 2 | Ken Hunte | Syracuse | Bellmore | NY | Mepham |
| 1950 | 155 | 2 | Ken Hunte | Syracuse | Bellmore | NY | Mepham |
| 1950 | 165 | 2 | James LaRock | Ithaca | Ithaca | NY | Ithaca |
| 1950 | 175 | 4 | Dan Mantrone | Auburn | Queens | NY | John Adams (Queens) |
| 1951 | 167 | 2 | George Graveson | Yale | Amityville | NY | Wyoming Seminary |
| 1952 | 121 | 4 | Robert Carlin | Indiana | Bainbridge | NY | Norwich |
| 1952 | 130 | 3 | Dick Lemyre | Penn State | Bellmore | NY | Mepham |
| 1952 | 167 | 1 | Joe Lemyre | Penn State | Bellmore | NY | Mepham |
| 1953 | 115 | 4 | Art Helf | Franklin & Marshall | Bellmore | NY | Mepham |
| 1953 | 130 | 2 | Dick Lemyre | Penn State | Bellmore | NY | Mepham |
| 1953 | 130 | 3 | Jim Howard | Ithaca | Vestal | NY | Vestal |
| 1953 | 147 | 1 | Frank Bettucci | Cornell | Ithaca | NY | Ithaca |
| 1953 | 147 | 3 | Don Frey | Penn State | Newton | NY | Newton |
| 1953 | 167 | 3 | Joe Lemyre | Penn State | Bellmore | NY | Mepham |
| 1954 | 130 | 2 | Jim Howard | Ithaca | Vestal | NY | Vestal |
| 1954 | 157 | 2 | Ed Rooney | Syracuse | Bellmore | NY | Mepham |
| 1955 | 123 | 4 | Daniel Deppe | Michigan | Hempstead | NY | Mepham |
| 1955 | 157 | 2 | Ed Rooney | Syracuse | Bellmore | NY | Mepham |
| 1956 | 137 | 4 | Joe Gratto | Lehigh | Canton | NY | Canton Central |
| 1957 | 137 | 1 | Joe Gratto | Lehigh | Canton | NY | Canton Central |
| 1957 | 157 | 4 | Bob Koster | Williams | Brooklyn | NY | |
| 1958 | 147 | 2 | Dick Vincent | Cornell | Castile | NY | Letchworth |
| 1958 | 177 | 2 | Tim Woodin | Michigan State | Ithaca | NY | Ithaca |
| 1959 | 123 | 1 | Dave Auble | Cornell | Ithaca | NY | Ithaca |
| 1959 | 191 | 2 | Tim Woodin | Michigan State | Ithaca | NY | Ithaca |
| 1959 | UNL | 2 | Bob Marella | Ithaca | Rochester | NY | Rochester Jefferson |
| 1960 | 123 | 1 | Dave Auble | Cornell | Ithaca | NY | Ithaca |
| 1960 | 137 | 2 | Lester Austin | Syracuse | Amityville | NY | Amityville |
| 1960 | 191 | 2 | Jack Stanbro | Ithaca | Homer | NY | Homer |
| 1963 | 137 | 6 | Gary Wilcox | Michigan | Syracuse | NY | Vestal |
| 1963 | 147 | 4 | Dick Slutzky | Syracuse | Massapequa | NY | Massapequa |
| 1963 | 191 | 6 | Gerry Everling | Syracuse | Binghamton | NY | Chenango Forks |
| 1964 | 115 | 5 | Chuck Bush | Cornell | Windsor | NY | Windsor |
| 1964 | 130 | 3 | Mark Piven | Penn State | Mepham | NY | Mepham |
| 1964 | 130 | 5 | Ted Lansky | Penn | Scarsdale | NY | Scarsdale |
| 1964 | 137 | 2 | Gary Wilcox | Michigan | Syracuse | NY | Vestal |
| 1964 | 157 | 2 | Dick Slutzky | Syracuse | Massapequa | NY | Massapequa |
| 1964 | 157 | 6 | Geoff Stephens | Cornell | Chenango Forks | NY | Chenango Forks |
| 1965 | 115 | 4 | Rich Warnke | Lehigh | Massapequa | NY | Massapequa |
| 1965 | 147 | 2 | Joe Bavaro | Gettysburg | Island Park | NY | Oceanside |
| 1965 | 157 | 6 | Geoff Stephens | Cornell | Chenango Forks | NY | Chenango Forks |
| 1965 | 167 | 4 | Ken Haltenhoff | Yale | Merrick | NY | Calhoun |
| 1966 | 123 | 4 | Warren Crow | Albany | Linton | NY | Linton |
| 1966 | 152 | 2 | Joe Bavaro | Gettysburg | Island Park | NY | Oceanside |
| 1966 | 191 | 5 | John Nichols | Navy | Saratoga Falls | NY | Saratoga |
| 1966 | UNL | 4 | Steve Shippos | Iowa State | Ithaca | NY | Ithaca |
| 1967 | 123 | 6 | Bill DeSario | Cortland State | Bellmore | NY | Mepham |
| 1967 | 137 | 5 | Don New | Cornell | Canastota | NY | Canastota |
| 1967 | 145 | 5 | Pete Vanderlofske | Navy | St. James | NY | Smithtown |
| 1967 | 160 | 6 | Jerry Stone | Oklahoma State | Sidney | NY | Sidney |
| 1967 | 191 | 1 | Tom Schlendorf | Syracuse | Merrick | NY | Calhoun |
| 1968 | 115 | 1 | Ken Melchior | Lock Haven | Lindenhurst | NY | Lindenhurst |
| 1968 | 123 | 4 | Bill DeSario | Cortland State | Bellmore | NY | Mepham |
| 1968 | 137 | 3 | Pete Vanderlofske | Navy | St. James | NY | Smithtown |
| 1968 | 137 | 4 | Marty Willigan | Hofstra | Amityville | NY | Amityville |
| 1968 | 137 | 6 | Ron Russo | Bloomsburg | Seaford | NY | Seaford |
| 1968 | 160 | 6 | Mike Nardotti | Army West Point | Hempstead | NY | Uniondale |
| 1968 | 177 | 5 | Dick Minekime | Cornell | Eden | NY | Eden |
| 1968 | 191 | 6 | Gary Seymour | Arizona State | Bainbridge | NY | Bainbridge-Guilford |
| 1968 | UNL | 5 | Dick Schumacher | East Stroudsburg | Suffern | NY | Suffern |
| 1969 | 115 | 5 | John Morley | MSU Moorhead | Oceanside | NY | Seaford |
| 1969 | 123 | 4 | Dave Waters | Lehigh | Farmingdale | NY | Farmingdale |
| 1969 | 137 | 2 | Marty Willigan | Hofstra | Amityville | NY | Amityville |
| 1969 | 137 | 4 | Ron Russo | Bloomsburg | Seaford | NY | Seaford |
| 1969 | 137 | 6 | Dick Humphreys | Indiana State | Golden | NY | Springville-Griffith |
| 1969 | 152 | 5 | Carl Adams | Iowa State | Brentwood | NY | Brentwood |
| 1969 | 160 | 5 | Joe Wiendl | Wilkes | Westfield | NY | Westfield |
| 1969 | 177 | 5 | John Sorochinsky | Brigham Young | Endicott | NY | Union Edicott |
| 1970 | 126 | 2 | Randy Payne | Pittsburgh | Sidney | NY | Sidney |
| 1970 | 177 | 5 | Steve Shields | Lehigh | Williston Park | NY | Herricks |
| 1970 | 190 | 2 | Bob Rust | Syracuse | Kenmore | NY | Kenmore East |
| 1970 | UNL | 5 | Dick Schumacher | East Stroudsburg | Suffern | NY | Suffern |
| 1971 | 118 | 2 | Tom Schuler | Navy | Babylon | NY | Babylon |
| 1971 | 142 | 5 | Tim Whitaker | Kent State | Rochester | NY | Monroe (Rochester) |
| 1971 | 150 | 3 | Don Stone | Penn State | Levittown | NY | Shamokin |
| 1971 | 150 | 6 | Paul Gillespie | West Chester | Baldwin | NY | Baldwin |
| 1971 | 158 | 1 | Carl Adams | Iowa State | Brentwood | NY | Brentwood |
| 1971 | 167 | 2 | Steve Shields | Lehigh | Williston Park | NY | Herricks |
| 1971 | 190 | 2 | Vince Paolano | Syracuse | North Bellmore | NY | Calhoun |
| 1972 | 118 | 4 | Tom Schuler | Navy | Babylon | NY | Babylon |
| 1972 | 158 | 1 | Carl Adams | Iowa State | Brentwood | NY | Brentwood |
| 1974 | 118 | 2 | Jack Spates | Slippery Rock | Smithtown | NY | Smithtown |
| 1974 | 126 | 5 | Bob Antonacci | Iowa State | Brentwood | NY | Brentwood |
| 1974 | 134 | 6 | Fred Hahndorf | Navy | Farmingdale | NY | Farmingdale |
| 1974 | 142 | 4 | Paul Gillespie | West Chester | Baldwin | NY | Baldwin |
| 1974 | 177 | 3 | Rob Huizenga | Michigan | Rochester | NY | Rochester |
| 1974 | 177 | 6 | Kurt Blank | Ohio | Rochester | NY | Irondequoit |
| 1975 | 118 | 4 | Nick Gallo | Hofstra | Deer Park | NY | Deer Park |
| 1975 | 126 | 5 | Bob Antonacci | Iowa State | Brentwood | NY | Brentwood |
| 1975 | 150 | 4 | Pete Galea | Iowa State | Brentwood | NY | Brentwood |
| 1975 | 158 | 2 | John Janiak | Syracuse | Syracuse | NY | North Syracuse |
| 1975 | 177 | 3 | Willie Gadson | Iowa State | Huntington | NY | Huntington |
| 1975 | 190 | 2 | Greg Stevens | Iowa | Fulton | NY | Bedford |
| 1976 | 126 | 4 | Bob Sloand | Lehigh | Niagara | NY | Niagara Wheatfield |
| 1976 | 126 | 6 | Joe Goldsmith | Southern Illinois | Spring Valley | NY | Ramapo |
| 1976 | 142 | 2 | Gene Costello | Slippery Rock | Bay Shore | NY | Bay Shore |
| 1976 | 150 | 2 | Pete Galea | Iowa State | Brentwood | NY | Brentwood |
| 1976 | 150 | 6 | Ken Wilson | Syracuse | Jordan | NY | Jordan-Elbridge |
| 1976 | 177 | 6 | Willie Gadson | Iowa State | Huntington | NY | Huntington |
| 1977 | 126 | 1 | Nick Gallo | Hofstra | Deer Park | NY | Deer Park |
| 1977 | 134 | 6 | George Medina | Syracuse | Baldwinsville | NY | Baldwinsville |
| 1977 | 158 | 5 | Keith Stearns | Oklahoma | Yorkshire | NY | Yorkshire Pioneer |
| 1978 | 134 | 2 | Frank DeAngelis | Oklahoma | Spencerport | NY | Spencerport |
| 1978 | 158 | 3 | John Janiak | Syracuse | Syracuse | NY | North Syracuse |
| 1978 | 158 | 6 | William Smith | Morgan State | Mount Vernon | NY | Mount Vernon |
| 1978 | 167 | 1 | Keith Stearns | Oklahoma | Yorkshire | NY | Yorkshire Pioneer |
| 1978 | 177 | 3 | Charles Gadson | Iowa State | Huntington | NY | Huntington |
| 1978 | UNL | 6 | Jeff Blatnick | Springfield | Schenectady | NY | Niskayuna |
| 1979 | UNL | 3 | Jeff Blatnick | Springfield | Schenectady | NY | Niskayuna |
| 1980 | 118 | 5 | Mike Piccozzi | Iowa State | Huntington | NY | Huntington |
| 1980 | 126 | 6 | Mike Giustizia | Tennessee | Huntington | NY | Whitman |
| 1980 | 126 | 8 | Jeff Thomas | Michigan State | Huntington | NY | Huntington |
| 1980 | 158 | 2 | William Smith | Morgan State | Mount Vernon | NY | Mount Vernon |
| 1980 | 158 | 4 | Tom Pickard | Iowa State | Baldwinsville | NY | Baldwinsville |
| 1980 | 167 | 5 | Lee Spiegel | Rhode Island | Mepham | NY | Mepham |
| 1980 | 177 | 1 | Ed Banach | Iowa | Port Jervis | NY | Port Jervis |
| 1980 | 177 | 6 | Ben Hill | Tennessee | Hampton Bay | NY | Hampton Bays |
| 1980 | 190 | 1 | Noel Loban | Clemson | Copiague | NY | Copiague |
| 1981 | 126 | 4 | Ed Pidgeon | Hofstra | Locust Valley | NY | Locust Valley |
| 1981 | 126 | 5 | John Iannuzzi | Wisconsin | Brentwood | NY | Brentwood Sonderling |
| 1981 | 134 | 6 | Clar Anderson | Auburn | Olean | NY | Olean |
| 1981 | 177 | 1 | Ed Banach | Iowa | Port Jervis | NY | Port Jervis |
| 1981 | 177 | 5 | Dave Young | Missouri | Lancaster | NY | Frontier |
| 1981 | 190 | 2 | Tony Mantella | Temple | Cortland | NY | Homer |
| 1981 | UNL | 1 | Lou Banach | Iowa | Port Jervis | NY | Port Jervis |
| 1982 | 126 | 5 | Frank Famiano | Brockport | Schenectady | NY | Draper |
| 1982 | 177 | 2 | Ed Banach | Iowa | Port Jervis | NY | Port Jervis |
| 1982 | 177 | 5 | Dave Young | Missouri | Lancaster | NY | Frontier |
| 1982 | UNL | 3 | Lou Banach | Iowa | Port Jervis | NY | Port Jervis |
| 1983 | 126 | 6 | Frank Famiano | Brockport | Schenectady | NY | Draper |
| 1983 | 134 | 1 | Clar Anderson | Oklahoma State | Olean | NY | Olean |
| 1983 | 142 | 4 | Andy McNerney | Harvard | Wading River | NY | Shoreham Wading River |
| 1983 | 150 | 8 | Ron Winnie | Brockport | Spencerport | NY | Spencerport |
| 1983 | 167 | 7 | Pete Capone | Hofstra | Watertown | NY | Watertown |
| 1983 | 177 | 7 | Wayne Catan | Tennessee | Jamaica | NY | Bellport |
| 1983 | 190 | 1 | Ed Banach | Iowa | Port Jervis | NY | Port Jervis |
| 1983 | UNL | 1 | Lou Banach | Iowa | Port Jervis | NY | Port Jervis |
| 1984 | 118 | 1 | Carl DeStefanis | Penn State | Locust Valley | NY | Locust Valley |
| 1984 | 134 | 5 | Clar Anderson | Oklahoma State | Olean | NY | Olean |
| 1984 | 150 | 8 | Chris Bevilacqua | Penn State | Massapequa | NY | Berner |
| 1984 | 167 | 4 | Chris Edmond | Tennessee | Freeport | NY | Freeport |
| 1984 | 167 | 6 | Rudy Isom | Wisconsin | Babylon | NY | North Babylon |
| 1984 | 190 | 5 | Jim Beichner | Clarion | Sinclairsville | NY | Cassadaga Valley |
| 1984 | 190 | 6 | Paul Diekel | Lehigh | Whitehall | NY | Whitehall Central |
| 1984 | 190 | 8 | Tod Giles | Boston University | Spring Valley | NY | Ramapo |
| 1985 | 142 | 3 | Peter Yozzo | Lehigh | Sayville | NY | Sayville |
| 1985 | 150 | 4 | Chris Bevilacqua | Penn State | Massapequa | NY | Berner |
| 1985 | 158 | 8 | Glen Lanham | Tennessee | Lindenhurst | NY | Lindenhurst |
| 1985 | 167 | 1 | Chris Edmond | Tennessee | Freeport | NY | Freeport |
| 1985 | 167 | 2 | Pete Capone | Hofstra | Watertown | NY | Watertown |
| 1985 | 177 | 2 | Wayne Catan | Syracuse | Jamaica | NY | Bellport |
| 1985 | 190 | 3 | Paul Diekel | Lehigh | Whitehall | NY | Whitehall Central |
| 1985 | 190 | 5 | Mark Cody | Missouri | Binghamton | NY | Binghamton |
| 1985 | 190 | 6 | Jim Beichner | Clarion | Sinclairsville | NY | Cassadaga Valley |
| 1986 | 118 | 2 | Al Palacio | North Carolina | Long Beach | NY | Long Beach |
| 1986 | 126 | 1 | Brad Penrith | Iowa | Windsor | NY | Windsor |
| 1986 | 126 | 3 | Steve DePetro | Northwestern | Wayne | NY | DePaul |
| 1986 | 142 | 2 | Peter Yozzo | Lehigh | Sayville | NY | Sayville |
| 1986 | 177 | 2 | Wayne Catan | Syracuse | Jamaica | NY | Bellport |
| 1986 | 190 | 5 | Paul Diekel | Lehigh | Whitehall | NY | Whitehall Central |
| 1987 | 118 | 7 | Al Palacio | North Carolina | Long Beach | NY | Long Beach |
| 1987 | 118 | 8 | Dennis Mejias | Wilkes | Bellmore | NY | Mepham |
| 1987 | 126 | 2 | Brad Penrith | Iowa | Windsor | NY | Windsor |
| 1987 | 134 | 8 | Andre Miller | Wilkes | Bayshore | NY | Central Islip |
| 1987 | 142 | 1 | Peter Yozzo | Lehigh | Sayville | NY | Sayville |
| 1987 | 158 | 5 | Glen Lanham | Oklahoma State | Lindenhurst | NY | Lindenhurst |
| 1987 | 158 | 8 | Brian Kurlander | James Madison | Rochester | NY | Brighton |
| 1987 | 177 | 3 | Dan Mayo | Penn State | Lake Ronkonkoma | NY | Sachem |
| 1988 | 126 | 2 | Brad Penrith | Iowa | Windsor | NY | Windsor |
| 1988 | 177 | 2 | Dan Mayo | Penn State | Lake Ronkonkoma | NY | Sachem |
| 1989 | 134 | 6 | Anibal Nieves | East Stroudsburg | Spring Lake | NY | Ellensville |
| 1989 | 167 | 5 | Jason Morris | Syracuse | Scotia | NY | Ballston Lake |
| 1990 | 118 | 5 | Jeff Prescott | Penn State | Olean | NY | Olean |
| 1990 | 134 | 8 | Rich Santana | Syracuse | Long Beach | NY | Long Beach |
| 1991 | 118 | 1 | Jeff Prescott | Penn State | Olean | NY | Olean |
| 1991 | 118 | 3 | Adam Derengowski | Rider | Harrington | NY | Paul VI |
| 1991 | 118 | 4 | Lou Rosselli | Edinboro | Middlesport | NY | Royalton Hartland |
| 1991 | 134 | 5 | Rich Santana | Syracuse | Long Beach | NY | Long Beach |
| 1991 | 150 | 6 | Nick Garone | Old Dominion | Patchogue | NY | Patchogue-Medford |
| 1991 | 158 | 2 | Tom Ryan | Iowa | Wantagh | NY | Wantagh |
| 1992 | 118 | 1 | Jeff Prescott | Penn State | Olean | NY | Olean |
| 1992 | 142 | 7 | Tom Shifflet | Edinboro | Amherst | NY | Sweet Home |
| 1992 | 158 | 3 | Tom Ryan | Iowa | Wantagh | NY | Wantagh |
| 1993 | 118 | 3 | Lou Rosselli | Edinboro | Middleport | NY | Royalton Hartland |
| 1993 | 126 | 5 | David Hirsch | Cornell | West Nyack | NY | Clarkstown South |
| 1993 | 142 | 6 | Tom Shifflet | Edinboro | Amherst | NY | Sweet Home |
| 1994 | 126 | 1 | David Hirsch | Cornell | West Nyack | NY | Clarkstown South |
| 1994 | 177 | 1 | Dean Morrison | West Virginia | Amityville | NY | Copiague |
| 1994 | 190 | 4 | Emilio Collins | Michigan State | Upper Nyack | NY | Tappan Zee |
| 1994 | 275 | 1 | Kerry McCoy | Penn State | Middle Island | NY | Longwood |
| 1995 | 142 | 3 | Tom Shifflet | Edinboro | Amherst | NY | Sweet Home |
| 1995 | 190 | 3 | Emilio Collins | Michigan State | Upper Nyack | NY | Tappan Zee |
| 1995 | 275 | 3 | Kerry McCoy | Penn State | Middle Island | NY | Longwood |
| 1995 | 275 | 5 | Nick Hall | Old Dominion | Middle Island | NY | Longwood |
| 1995 | 275 | 7 | Dan Payne | Clarion | Victor | NY | Victor |
| 1997 | 118 | 7 | John Carvalheira | Rider | Farmingdale | NY | Sachem |
| 1997 | 126 | 6 | Terry Showalter | Lock Haven | Canastota | NY | Canastota |
| 1997 | 177 | 2 | Mitch Clark | Ohio State | Canton | NY | Canton |
| 1997 | 275 | 1 | Kerry McCoy | Penn State | Middle Island | NY | Longwood |
| 1997 | 275 | 7 | Jason Gleasman | Syracuse | Boonville | NY | Adirondack Central |
| 1998 | 118 | 8 | John Carvalheira | Rider | Farmingdale | NY | Sachem |
| 1998 | 158 | 3 | John Lange | Penn State | Ridge | NY | Longwood |
| 1998 | 177 | 1 | Mitch Clark | Ohio State | Canton | NY | Canton |
| 1998 | 275 | 6 | Jason Gleasman | Syracuse | Boonville | NY | Adirondack Central |
| 1999 | 149 | 6 | Ryan Bernholz | Lehigh | Mount Sinai | NY | Mt. Sinai |
| 1999 | 197 | 3 | Nick Muzashvili | Michigan State | Unadilla | NY | Unatego |
| 1999 | 197 | 4 | Andrei Rodzianko | Penn | West Nyack | NY | Clarkstown South |
| 2000 | 125 | 2 | Steve Garland | Virginia | Middletown | NY | Middletown |
| 2000 | 197 | 4 | Nick Muzashvili | Michigan State | Unadilla | NY | Unatego |
| 2002 | 149 | 3 | Jesse Jantzen | Harvard | Shoreham | NY | Shoreham-Wading River |
| 2002 | 157 | 8 | Griff Powell | Illinois | Suffern | NY | Suffern |
| 2002 | 174 | 2 | Greg Parker | Princeton | Clifton Park | NY | Shenendehowa |
| 2002 | 285 | 7 | Dawid Rechul | Harvard | Huntington Station | NY | Huntington |
| 2003 | 149 | 3 | Jesse Jantzen | Harvard | Shoreham | NY | Shoreham-Wading River |
| 2003 | 149 | 7 | Jon Masa | Hofstra | Long Beach | NY | Long Beach |
| 2003 | 165 | 6 | John Clark | Ohio State | Canton | NY | Canton |
| 2003 | 174 | 2 | Carl Fronhofer | Pittsburgh | Salem | NY | Salem |
| 2003 | 184 | 8 | Greg Parker | Princeton | Clifton Park | NY | Niskayuna |
| 2004 | 149 | 1 | Jesse Jantzen | Harvard | Shoreham | NY | Shoreham-Wading River |
| 2004 | 165 | 5 | John Clark | Ohio State | Canton | NY | Canton |
| 2004 | 197 | 8 | Kyle Cerminaro | Buffalo | Lewiston | NY | Lewiston-Porter |
| 2005 | 149 | 3 | Jon Masa | Hofstra | Long Beach | NY | Long Beach |
| 2005 | 157 | 8 | Chris Horning | Clarion | Syracuse | NY | Baldwinsville |
| 2005 | 174 | 5 | Joe Mazzurco | Cornell | Mahopac | NY | Mahopac |
| 2006 | 125 | 2 | Troy Nickerson | Cornell | Chenango Forks | NY | Chenango Forks |
| 2006 | 149 | 5 | Jon Masa | Hofstra | Long Beach | NY | Long Beach |
| 2006 | 149 | 7 | Gregor Gillespie | Edinboro | Webster | NY | Webster Schroeder |
| 2006 | 174 | 4 | Mike Patrovich | Hofstra | Islip | NY | Islip |
| 2006 | 174 | 5 | Matt Herrington | Penn | Cambridge | NY | LaSalle Institute |
| 2006 | 184 | 4 | Josh Glenn | American | Johnson City | NY | Johnson City |
| 2006 | 184 | 6 | Joe Mazzurco | Cornell | Mahopac | NY | Mahopac |
| 2006 | 197 | 6 | Chris Weidman | Hofstra | Baldwin | NY | Baldwin |
| 2007 | 125 | 3 | Troy Nickerson | Cornell | Chenango Forks | NY | Chenango Forks |
| 2007 | 149 | 1 | Gregor Gillespie | Edinboro | Webster | NY | Webster Schroeder |
| 2007 | 149 | 5 | J.P. O’Connor | Harvard | Oxford | NY | Oxford Academy |
| 2007 | 157 | 4 | James Strouse | Hofstra | Levittown | NY | MacArthur |
| 2007 | 165 | 6 | Mike Patrovich | Hofstra | Islip | NY | Islip |
| 2007 | 197 | 1 | Josh Glenn | American | Johnson City | NY | Johnson City |
| 2007 | 197 | 3 | Chris Weidman | Hofstra | Baldwin | NY | Baldwin |
| 2008 | 149 | 6 | J.P. O’Connor | Harvard | Oxford | NY | Oxford Academy |
| 2008 | 157 | 5 | Gregor Gillespie | Edinboro | Webster | NY | Webster Schroeder |
| 2008 | 174 | 8 | Alton Lucas | Hofstra | West Babylon | NY | West Babylon |
| 2008 | 197 | 5 | Josh Glenn | American | Johnson City | NY | Johnson City |
| 2009 | 125 | 1 | Troy Nickerson | Cornell | Chenango Forks | NY | Chenango Forks |
| 2009 | 149 | 7 | Kyle Borshoff | American | Pittsford | NY | Pittsford Sutherland |
| 2009 | 157 | 4 | Gregor Gillespie | Edinboro | Webster | NY | Webster Schroeder |
| 2009 | 184 | 7 | Joshua Patterson | Binghamton | Wayne | NY | Wayne |
| 2010 | 125 | 4 | Troy Nickerson | Cornell | Chenango Forks | NY | Chenango Forks |
| 2010 | 141 | 1 | Kyle Dake | Cornell | Lansing | NY | Lansing |
| 2010 | 149 | 6 | Torsten Gillespie | Edinboro | Webster | NY | Webster Schroeder |
| 2010 | 149 | 8 | Kyle Borshoff | American | Pittsford | NY | Pittsford Sutherland |
| 2010 | 157 | 1 | J.P. O’Connor | Harvard | Oxford | NY | Oxford Academy |
| 2010 | 157 | 4 | Justin Lister | Binghamton | Adams | NY | South Jefferson |
| 2010 | 157 | 8 | Steven Brown | Central Michigan | Hermon | NY | Hermon-DeKalb Central |
| 2011 | 133 | 7 | Lou Ruggirello | Hofstra | Walden | NY | Valley Central |
| 2011 | 149 | 1 | Kyle Dake | Cornell | Lansing | NY | Lansing |
| 2011 | 165 | 8 | P.J. Gillespie | Hofstra | Webster | NY | Webster Schroeder |
| 2012 | 125 | 8 | Steve Bonanno | Hofstra | Wantagh | NY | Wantagh |
| 2012 | 133 | 8 | Steve Keith | Harvard | Shoreham | NY | Shoreham-Wading River |
| 2012 | 141 | 7 | Michael Nevinger | Cornell | Perry | NY | Letchworth Central |
| 2012 | 149 | 3 | Donnie Vinson | Binghamton | Marathon | NY | Whitney Point |
| 2012 | 157 | 1 | Kyle Dake | Cornell | Lansing | NY | Lansing |
| 2012 | 285 | 8 | Nick Gwiadzowski | NC State | Delanson | NY | Duanesburg |
| 2013 | 141 | 5 | Michael Nevinger | Cornell | Perry | NY | Letchworth Central |
| 2013 | 165 | 1 | Kyle Dake | Cornell | Lansing | NY | Lansing |
| 2014 | 141 | 7 | Steve Dutton | Michigan | Miller Place | NY | Rocky Point |
| 2014 | 157 | 6 | Brian Realbuto | Cornell | Somers | NY | Somers |
| 2014 | 285 | 1 | Nick Gwiadzowski | NC State | Delanson | NY | Duanesburg |
| 2015 | 157 | 2 | Brian Realbuto | Cornell | Somers | NY | Somers |
| 2015 | 285 | 1 | Nick Gwiadzowski | NC State | Delanson | NY | Duanesburg |
| 2016 | 157 | 4 | Dylan Palacio | Cornell | Long Beach | NY | Long Beach |
| 2016 | 165 | 5 | Steven Rodrigues | Illinois | Mount Kisco | NY | Fox Lane |
| 2016 | 285 | 2 | Nick Gwiadzowski | NC State | Delanson | NY | Duanesburg |
| 2017 | 125 | 4 | Nick Piccininni | Oklahoma State | East Setauket | NY | Ward Melville |
| 2017 | 157 | 6 | Dylan Palacio | Cornell | Long Beach | NY | Long Beach |
| 2017 | 174 | 5 | Brian Realbuto | Cornell | Somers | NY | Somers |
| 2018 | 141 | 1 | Yianni Diakomihalis | Cornell | Rochester | NY | Hilton |
| 2018 | 197 | 7 | Shakur Rasheed | Penn State | Coram | NY | Longwood |
| 2018 | 285 | 6 | Mike Hughes | Hofstra | Smithtown | NY | Smithtown West |
| 2018 | 285 | 8 | Youssif Hemida | Maryland | Mamaroneck | NY | Mamaroneck |
| 2019 | 125 | 4 | Vito Arujau | Cornell | Syosset | NY | Syosset |
| 2019 | 125 | 5 | Nick Piccininni | Oklahoma State | East Setauket | NY | Ward Melville |
| 2019 | 141 | 1 | Yianni Diakomihalis | Cornell | Rochester | NY | Hilton |
| 2019 | 197 | 8 | Ben Honis | Cornell | Syracuse | NY | Jamesville-Dewitt |
| 2019 | 285 | 6 | Youssif Hemida | Maryland | Mamaroneck | NY | Mamaroneck |
| 2021 | 157 | 2 | Jesse Dellavecchia | Rider | Great River | NY | East Islip |
| 2021 | 157 | 4 | Jacori Teemer | Arizona State | Long Beach | NY | Long Beach |
| 2021 | 184 | 8 | Lou DePrez | Binghamton | Hilton | NY | Hilton |
| 2022 | 125 | 3 | Vito Arujau | Cornell | Syosset | NY | Syosset |
| 2022 | 149 | 1 | Yianni Diakomihalis | Cornell | Rochester | NY | Hilton |
| 2022 | 157 | 6 | Jacori Teemer | Arizona State | Long Beach | NY | Long Beach |
| 2022 | 184 | 8 | Jonathan Loew | Cornell | Wantagh | NY | Wantagh |
| 2023 | 125 | 4 | Anthony Noto | Lock Haven | Lima | NY | Honeoye Falls-Lima |
| 2023 | 133 | 1 | Vito Arujau | Cornell | Syosset | NY | Syosset |
| 2023 | 149 | 1 | Yianni Diakomihalis | Cornell | Rochester | NY | Hilton |
| 2024 | 125 | 3 | Anthony Noto | Lock Haven | Lima | NY | Honeoye Falls-Lima |
| 2024 | 133 | 1 | Vito Arujau | Cornell | Syosset | NY | Syosset |
| 2024 | 157 | 2 | Jacori Teemer | Arizona State | Long Beach | NY | Long Beach |
| 2025 | 125 | 8 | Stevo Poulin | Northern Colorado | Ballston Lake | NY | Shenendehowa |
